CarEdge

Butler Toyota Jacksonville

Jacksonville, FL11 verified quotes*These quotes come from real negotiations by CarEdge members. Each quote shows actual pricing a customer received from this dealer.Data: Nov 15, 2025 - Dec 5, 2025Claim this page
A
CarEdgeVerified
Transparent Dealer
Score: 90/100
Shop Inventory904-903-2654Website
Doc FeeA documentation fee (doc fee) covers the dealer's cost for processing paperwork. It's legally required to be the same for all customers at a given dealership. In most states, this fee is negotiable.
$899
Avg Add-onsDealer add-ons are optional products like paint protection, window tinting, or anti-theft devices. These are often marked up significantly and can usually be declined or negotiated.
$17
Dealer MarkupThe percentage the dealer adds above the listing price in fees (doc fee, add-ons, and other charges). Taxes and government fees are excluded. Lower is better.
+0.0%
Avg NegotiatedThe difference between the first quote and final quote for the same vehicle. Shows how much was saved through negotiation.
$2,625

Butler Toyota Jacksonville Data-Driven Review

Based on 11 verified OTD quotes collected between Nov 2025 and Dec 2025, Butler Toyota Jacksonville earns a Grade A transparency score of 90/100. Their doc fee of $899 is $278 above the FL average ($621). When present, add-ons average $17, which is relatively low. Buyers who negotiated saved an average of $2,625.

Transparency Score BreakdownOur transparency score (0-100) measures how upfront dealers are about pricing. Higher scores mean lower doc fees, fewer add-ons, and prices closer to what's advertised.

Fee Transparency (30%)Measures doc fee fairness. Dealers charging at or below $499 score highest. Fees above $1,500 score lowest. Doc fees are the same for every customer at a dealership.72
Add-on Behavior (30%)Measures how often the dealer adds extra products to deals. Dealers who rarely push add-ons or keep them minimal score highest.95
Dealer Markup (30%)Measures dealer-controlled fees above the listed price, excluding taxes and title fees. Dealers with minimal markup score highest.100
Data Quality (10%)Measures how complete the pricing data is in our records. More complete data = more reliable scores.100
  • ✓Doc fee ($899) is at or below FL average ($999)
  • ✓Average dealer add-ons of $17 when present
  • ✓Dealer markup averages 0.0% above listing (excellent — minimal fees beyond the vehicle price)

Doc Fee Comparison

This dealer$899
FL avg$999
National avg$398

Recent QuotesThese quotes come from real negotiations by CarEdge members. Each quote shows actual pricing a customer received from this dealer.

2026 Toyota Grand Highlander

Hybrid Limited AWD

$59,971
Doc Fee$899
Add-onsNone
Savings$2,625

2022 Ford F-150

Raptor 4WD SuperCrew 5.5' B

$64,997
Doc Fee$899
Add-onsNone
Savings—

2024 Honda Ridgeline

RTL AWD

$35,989
Doc Fee$899
Add-ons$186
Savings—

Most Common Add-onsThe most frequently seen dealer add-ons at this dealer, based on itemized OTD quotes. Shows how often each add-on appears and the average price when present.

1
electronic tempavg $35
1 quote
2
batteryavg $2
1 quote
3
electronic filingavg $150
1 quote

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Butler Toyota Jacksonville's doc fee?

Butler Toyota Jacksonville charges a typical documentation fee of $899. The FL average is $621. This is based on 11 verified OTD quotes in our database.

Does Butler Toyota Jacksonville add mandatory add-ons?

Butler Toyota Jacksonville adds an average of $17 in dealer add-ons when present. Ask for an itemized breakdown and negotiate to remove non-essential items like paint protection, nitrogen tire fill, or VIN etching.

Is Butler Toyota Jacksonville a good dealer?

Butler Toyota Jacksonville has a transparency score of 90/100, earning a Grade A. This score is based on their doc fees, add-on behavior, dealer markup, and data quality from 11 verified OTD quotes. This is a well-above-average score, indicating transparent pricing practices.

At a Glance

Minimal dealer markup above listing price
CarEdge

Get an even better deal

Even with a transparent dealer, CarEdge Pro's AI agent can save you more. Average savings: $2,200.

  • AI agent negotiates OTD price for you
  • No hidden fees or add-ons
  • Avg savings: $2,200
Try CarEdge Pro

Tips for Butler Toyota Jacksonville

  • 📝Minor add-ons (~$17) may appear. Ask what's included and if they can be removed.
  • ⭐A-rated dealer! Focus on vehicle price negotiation—fees are already competitive.
  • ✅Doc fee ($899) is at or below FL average. One less thing to negotiate.
  • ✅Dealer markup is only +0% above listing (excluding taxes). This dealer keeps their fees minimal.

Data Summary

Total Quotes
11
Recent (12mo)
11
Complete Data
11

What to Expect

When shopping at Butler Toyota Jacksonville:

  • Expect a doc fee around $899
  • Add-ons may total around $17
  • OTD price is typically 0-1% above listing
How are scores calculated?Learn about our methodology →

*Information provided for general informational purposes only. Scores are independently calculated and do not imply endorsement of or affiliation with any dealer. Verify all information independently before making a purchase decision. See our Terms of Service.